The gaming world changed forever when Until Dawn burst onto the scene in 2015, redefining what interactive horror could be. With its butterfly effect system, where every choice had genuine consequences, and cinematically beautiful graphics that blurred the line between games and movies, it created a new standard for narrative-driven horror experiences. If you've finished Until Dawn and are hungry for more spine-chilling decision-based adventures, you're in the right place. Let's begin our journey through the best choice-driven horror experiences gaming has to offer in 2025. The Quarry Developer: Supermassive Games Platform: PC (Steam), PlayStation 4|5, Xbox Series X|S, Xbox One Release Date: 10 June 2022 Developed by Supermassive Games, the same studio behind Until Dawn, The Quarry is perhaps the closest spiritual successor you'll find. Set in Hackett's Quarry summer camp, this teen-horror adventure features: A star-studded cast including David Arquette and Ariel Winter 186 unique endings based on your choices Enhanced graphics utilizing Unreal Engine 4 More streamlined gameplay mechanics while maintaining depth Optional movie mode for those who prefer to watch the story unfold Local and online multiplayer options What sets it apart: The Quarry builds on Until Dawn's foundation with improved accessibility options and more nuanced character relationships. Heavy Rain Developer: Quantic Dream Platform: PC (Steam), PlayStation 3|4 Release Date: 18 February 2010 Heavy Rain stands as a groundbreaking interactive drama that revolutionized narrative-driven gaming. Like Until Dawn, it masterfully weaves multiple character perspectives into a gripping thriller, but takes a darker, more grounded approach. The game follows four protagonists whose lives intertwine in the hunt…